Evidence before adjectives

How App Village verifies app facts

A useful guide should make it easy to see what is known, what is editorial interpretation, and what still needs checking.

Illustrated App Village pond and bridge

The verification loop

Small claims, clear sources

Identify

Match the app name, developer, category, description, and App Store destination using current project records and the visible listing destination.

Separate

Keep factual metadata distinct from a developer's positioning, App Village's editorial judgment, and any commercial placement.

Qualify

Only include an app in a constraint guide when evidence supports that exact constraint. Missing evidence remains “not verified,” not “probably true.”

Date-sensitive facts

Treat price, availability, subscriptions, in-app purchases, privacy labels, and platform support as facts that can change.

Avoid false precision

Do not publish rankings, scores, aggregate ratings, test results, or comparisons without a documented basis.

Correct

Update a page when a material fact changes or a developer provides reliable evidence. Keep the page's scope honest while verification is pending.

Source hierarchy

  1. App Store destination and developer materials: useful for identity, availability, product description, platform support, and current purchase information when visible.
  2. App Village's structured project record: the source for the four current factual listings, their descriptions, categories, displayed prices, developers, and destinations.
  3. App Village editorial material: useful for the site's intended audience and selection principles, but not proof of an individual app's privacy, account, or subscription behavior.

Constraint-guide rule

Words such as “no subscription,” “no account,” “private,” and “Apple Watch” are independently verified fields. One field never stands in for another. A fixed displayed price does not prove no subscriptions; “kept on your iPhone” does not prove a complete privacy model; “free” does not describe in-app purchases.

Current scope and ownership

Disclosure. The four current verified listings—Koala Journal: Voice Diary, Caffeine Tracker: Bedtime, Sunscreen Buddy: UV Reminder, and Blind Box Tracker—are developed by Nicholas Wong. Nicholas also owns and edits App Village. These pages are first-party factual listings, not independent tests. Future sponsored storefronts must be disclosed, and payment does not buy editorial praise.

Read the guides